Railroading an Icon

By Jim Posewitz

Should Senate Bill 143 [B1] pass this legislature it will be a historical landmark of considerable significance. It will mark the point where a rich Montana wildlife conservation ethic held since our territorial years was jammed into a shuddering reverse.

When the first Territorial Legislature convened, brothers James and Granville Stuart were members and they came with a fish and wildlife conservation ethic. James won passage of legislation protecting fish by restricting harvest to hook and line fishing. It’s noteworthy that this legislation became Montana law 12 years before Custer bit the dust at the Little Big Horn.

As early as 1872, Granville Stuart successfully championed legislation providing some closed season protection for “… mountain buffalo, moose, elk, black-tailed deer, white-tailed deer, mountain sheep, white Rocky Mountain goat, (and) antelope ….” [1] All through Montana’s territorial years the Stuarts led efforts to curb the commercial carnage of fish and wildlife, there was however, little means of enforcing what Stuart fought for so valiantly. At one point a frustrated Granville wrote: “If the legislature does not enact some laws in regard to game and fish, there will not be in a few years so much as a minnow or a deer left alive in all the territory.” [2]

A Montana wildlife conservation ethic was held by the people and they, through their legislators, asserted that ethic through the years. In fact this 2013 session marks the 100th anniversary of State Senator T.O. Larsen (R) from Choteau introducing and passing a bill to create the Sun River Game Preserve to promote wildlife recovery. The bill passed the Senate on a vote of 26 to 0 – with 6 absent or not voting. Governor Sam V. Stewart (D) signed the Bill. [3] There obviously was a legislative conservation ethic in 1913 and it was clearly beyond political party ideology.

Now, a century later, that vision and foresight has provided Montana with the moniker, “The Last, Best Place.” That identity fits because of the fish and wildlife that has been restored and nurtured since James and Granville Stuart pointed us toward the higher ground. Today, we stand poised and capable of topping off this conservation legacy by adding the one species that paid the highest price in this epic struggle of wildlife restoration; Buffalo. The Montana people clearly support a modest level of wild buffalo restoration. Nobody with any credibility is talking about herds thousands strong running through the breaks. What we are talking about is small, isolated herds that fit with the available landscapes, while minimizing the conflict between Montanans. However, Senate Bill 143 of the 2013 Montana Legislature, simply says kill them all – anyone, on any day – kill them all.

In 1872 our Territorial Legislature found the liquidation of buffalo shameful. Today, that conservation ethic and the dedication to our Tribal neighbors apparently has vanished. Exactly a century ago the 1913 Montana State Legislature gave overwhelming approval to the quest for a better way, a more profound relationship with Montana wildlife. It would be shameful indeed to observe the centennial of the 1913 commitment to conservation with legislation of liquidation – Senate Bill 143. We need to listen to and heed the counsel of our forefathers. We need to demand a resounding no vote on Senate Bill 143.

If passed, this bill would eliminate the Yellowstone Bison hunt, eliminate game animal status for bison, keep tribes from growing their own bison herds and continue to wasteful and tragic slaughter of America’s grandest land mammal.

Contact the Senate Fish and Game Committee and tell them that we will not stand for this:

Brad Hamlett senatorhamlett@gmail.com

Debby Barrett grt3177@smtel.com

Fred Thomas Sfredthomas@yahoo.com

Jennifer Fielder GetitRight@montana.com

Jim Peterson jpetersonranch@gmail.com

John Brenden senatorbrenden@gmail.com

Kendall Van Dyke kendallvandyke@gmail.com

Larry Jent larry@imt.net

Rick Ripley ripleys@3rivers.net

Tom Facey facey_tom@hotmail.com

Do you like this post?

Be the first to comment


Hellgate Hunters and Anglers
Our Mission is to conserve Montana's wildlife, wild places, and fair-chase hunting and fishing heritage.